(Draft)
2010 ANNUAL MEETING
June 11 – 13, 2010
-
Gathering Music:
Each time the delegates to the 2010 Annual Meeting of the Maine Conference
gathered in the Dearborn Gymnasium at the
Call to order: Moderator Anita White called the meeting to order.
Official Call of the 2010 Annual Meeting
The 79th Annual Meeting of the Maine Conference of
the United Church of Christ (successor to the Congregational Christian
Conference of Maine; it being the 99th Anniversary of the Congregational
Conference and Missionary Society of Maine; the 185th Anniversary of the State
Conference, the 203rd Anniversary of the Maine Missionary Society, the 181st
Anniversary of the Maine Congregational Ministerial Relief Society, and the
43rd Anniversary of the Maine Conference as a Conference of the United Church
of Christ), will be held at the University of Maine, Farmington, Maine and will
convene at 2:30 p.m., Friday, June 11, 2010.
Items to be voted at this year’s meeting will be the:
·
Proposed 2011 Conference Budget
·
2011
Compensation Guidelines for Clergy
·
Slate
of Officers/Commissions Elect
·
Resolution
regarding “Covenant for Civil Discourse”
·
Changes
to the
Quorum: Moderator Anita White, after consultation with the Credentials Committee, declared that a quorum as defined by the Conference Bylaws was present.
Constituting Prayer: Doug Nielsen offered the constituting prayer.
Appointment of Credentials
Committee, Tellers, and Parliamentarian: Moderator Anita White announced
the appointment of the following:
Credentials Committee: George Kimball,
Sue Stevens,
Tellers: Anne Roundy, Don Green, Linda
Kimball, Marcia Charles, Ben
Haskell,
Parliamentarian: Sally Colegrove
Approval of September 25 – 27, 2009 Annual Meeting Minutes: The minutes of the September 25 – 27, 2009 Annual Meeting were accepted as printed. The motion passed with no opposition or abstentions.
Receipt of Printed Reports: The reports distributed prior to the Annual Meeting were received as printed.
Greetings from
Greetings from the
Introduction of Conference Staff: Rev. David Gaewski offered a audio-visual presentation of the Conference staff.
Treasurer’s Report: Supported by multiple graphs and charts, Treasurer Gerard Moore presented his report to the Annual Meeting delegates. His presentation included a review of both the income and expenditures. He indicated that the recent audit had produced no significant findings. He noted that the invested funds had started to recover from last year’s losses. He also pointed out, however, that the cash flow has necessitated short-term borrowing in March. The Treasurer’s report was accepted as printed.
2011 Budget Presentation, Discussion, and Vote: Connie Insley, chair of the Finance Committee, used graphs and charts to present the proposed 2011 budget that was developed by that committee and recommended by the Coordinating Council. The 2011 budget was adopted as presented on a hand vote.
Coordinating Council Recommendation, Discussion, and Vote: Vice Moderator Herb Oliver introduced a motion from the Coordinating Council that 5% of the net proceeds of the sale of the Rockcraft Retreat Center be given as an unrestricted gift to the National Setting of the United Church of Christ. The Coordinating Council’s recommendation was based on the fact that the amount of Our Church’s Wider Mission funds forwarded to the National Setting had been reduced by the Coordinating Council in a revision of the adopted 2009 budget, had been further reduced in the adopted 2010 budget, and was being recommended for even further reduction in the proposed 2011 budget.
After considerable discussion, a motion to table the motion was defeated on a hand vote.
An amendment to the motion, designating the
Maine Council of Churches as the recipient of an additional 5% of the net proceeds
of the sale of the
The original motion (the Coordinating Council’s recommendation) was then defeated on a hand vote. Several delegates expressed the opinion that no commitments of the net proceeds should be made until the amount of the sale is known. Others felt that decisions about the disposition of the proceeds should be made only after the Coordinating Council had provided a plan for the expenditure of those proceeds.
A motion was made that this Annual Meeting go on record asking the Coordinating Council, as it considers the use of the Rockcraft Retreat Center funds, take seriously generous donations to both the Maine Council of Churches and the National Church. The motion was tabled on a hand vote.
With time drawing near to the end of Plenary 1, a motion to extend the order of the day (to continue the discussion) was defeated on a hand vote.
Speak Out Overview: Anne Roundy reviewed the procedures that would be used in conjunction with the Speak Out sessions at the Annual Meeting. Those wishing to present information at the Speak Out sessions would be given one minute and could sign up for one of the Speak Outs. Anne would invite the listed persons to the microphone and monitor the time of their presentation.
Plenary 1 ended at 4:30 p.m.
Workshops – Session 1: The following workshops were scheduled from 11:00 a.m. to 12:00 noon:
Title Room Leader
Morning Small Group Discussion
Reframing
Reframing Stewardship
Recognizing Invisible Barriers Thomas Auditorium Stephen Carnahan
Reframing Our Families
Reframing Evangelism
Evening Session – Friday, June 11, 2010, 6:30 – 8:30 p.m.
State of the Conference Address – Rev. David Gaewski: Rev. David Gaewski, Conference Minister, presented his annual State of the Conference Address. He included the following concerns and celebrations in his address:
Worship with
Rev. Carol Howard Merritt: Rev. Carol Howard Merritt, Pastor of the Western
Presbyterian Church,
Rev. Merritt’s theme for the Friday evening worship service was “shifting landscapes.’ She identified four specific areas in which the “landscape” of the church’s work has or is changing and gave examples of each:
1. Community – The new community members coming to our churches often reflect a need to question authority and a breakdown of individualism in favor of a new sense of community. Examples included churches that are borrowing from different traditions rather than following strict denominational lines and monastic churches that offer contemplative services rather than liturgical guidelines.
2. Technology – There is a pronounced shift from the “signpost and commerce” churches to “social media” churches where personal relationships are developed as the basis for worship and interaction. Examples given were the use of Facebook and other social media technologies for more personal and directed communication and interaction.
3. Narrative – The themes of the emerging churches tend to emphasize personal experiences, testimonies, and “personal, family, and community stories” rather that preaching and teaching in the traditional sense. Evangelism is given a new meaning.
4. Activism – The new community members tend to be more interested in social issues than either biblical study or personal faith development. An example is the “Not for sale” program that promotes political and social activities concerning the issue of human bondage and trafficking.
Speak Out 1 – Moderated by Anne Roundy
Conference Bylaw Revision, Discussion, and Vote: Walter (Ted) Ruark, chair of the Bylaw Revision Committee, presented the revised Bylaws as recommended by the Coordinating Council. The Bylaws, as revised, were adopted with no comments on a hand vote.
Recognition of 5 for 5 Churches: Rev. David Gaewski, Rev. Susan Craig, and Rev. Darren Morgan read the names of the churches in the Maine Conference which had collected all 5 of the annual appeals of the United Church of Christ (Basic Support, One Great Hour of Sharing, Neighbors in Need, Strengthening the Church, and The Christmas Fund):
Alfred
Congregational UCC,
West Parish Congregational
UCC,
First
Congregational UCC, Bridgton
Brownville
Community Church UCC, Brownville
First Parish
Church UCC,
Elm Street
Congregational, Bucksport
Casco Village
Church UCC, Casco
Trinitarian Parish
Church UCC, Castine
First Congregational
Church UCC,
First
Congregational UCC, Eastport
Union
Congregational UCC,
First
Congregational, UCC,
First
Congregational UCC, Fryeburg
First
Congregational UCC, Gray
First
Congregational Church UCC, Houlton
Second Christian
Congregational UCC,
First
Congregational Church UCC, Kittery Point
Limerick
Congregational UCC,
Lovell United
New Sharon
Congregational, UCC, New Sharon
Second
Congregational UCC,
Second
Congregational UCC,
First
Congregational UCC,
Williston-West
UCC,
Woodfords
Congregational UCC,
Presque Isle
Congregational Church UCC, Presque Isle
Raymond, Village Community UCC, Raymond
East Raymond Chapel, Raymond
First Parish UCC,
North Parish Congregational UCC, Sanford
Somesville Union Meeting House UCC, Somesville
First Congregational UCC,
State Youth Council
Recognition of Churches with Increases in Our Church’s Wider Mission of at least 10%: Rev. David Gaewski, Rev. Susan Craig, and Rev. Darren Morgan read the names of the churches in the Maine Conference which had increased their contributions to Our Church’s Wider Mission by at least 10% (comparing 2009 giving to 2008 giving):
First Congregational UCC, Brewer
Dover-Foxcroft Congregational UCC, Dover-Foxcroft
First Congregational UCC, Buxton
Centre Street Congregational UCC, Machais
West Newfield Congregational UCC,
Central Congregational UCC, Eastport
First Congregational UCC, Edgecomb
Second Congregational UCC,
Williston-West Congregational UCC,
Second Christian Congregational,
UCC of
State Street Congregational UCC,
First Congregational UCC,
10 churches gave in 2009 but not in 2008
34 churches increased in 2009
41 churches gave same as 2009
` 53 church decreased in 2009
28 churches gave nothing in 2009
166 churches total
Recognition of Open and
Somesville Union Meeting House Mt Desert
United
First Parish Congregational Church
Woodfords Congregational Church,
UCC
First Congregational Church
First Congregational Church UCC
First Parish Congregational Church UCC Gorham
Union Congregational Church Hancock
Williston West UCC
The Union Church of
The Union Congregational Church
First Congregational Church UCC
State Street Congregational Church
UCC
First Congregational UCC Blue Hill
Old South, First Congregational
Church
The Open House
Windham Hill UCC
Broad Bay Congregational UCC Waldoboro
Old South Congregational Church UCC Hallowell
Centre Street Congregational Church UCC Machias
The
ONA Spirited Youth Organization -
Associate Conference Minister’s Remarks:
Rev. Susan Craig thanked the
Conference for the opportunity to serve the churches of
Associate Conference Minister
for
Nominating Committee Report and Election: Eric Smith presented the slate of nominees:
Coordinating Council
(2012)
Moderator: Herb Oliver,
(2012)
Vice Moderator: Rev. Doug Nielsen,
(2012) Clerk: Walter (Ted) Ruark, Augusta
(2012) Treasurer: John Davidson, Lincoln
(2013) At Large: Rev. Karen Byrne, Winslow
(2013)
At Large: Jeff McDonnell,
(2013)
At Large: Linette George,
(2013)
At Large: Rev. Kent Allen,
Board of Trustees
(2013-1)
Rev. Linda Gard, New
(2013-1)
Ted Davis,
(2013-2)
Rev. Martha Hoverson,
Nominating
Committee
(2013)
Laurie McQuarrie,
(2013)
Rev. Anita White,
Commission
for Community Life
(2013-2)
Nancy Godfrey,
Commission
for Spiritual Life
(2013-1)
Doug Dunlap,
Commission
for Witness Life
(2013-1)
Steve Carnahan,
General
Synod Delegates
(2013)
(2013)
Hancock-Waldo: Briana Haynes,
(2013)
(2013)
Midcoast: Tim Gormley,
(2013)
Moderator:
Herb Oliver,
State Youth Council (to be named in February 2011)
Eric Smith moved that the Nominating Committee report be accepted and that the Clerk cast one ballot for the nominees. The motion carried on a hand vote without opposition or abstentions.
Coordinating Council
Recommendation, Discussion, and Vote: Discussion of the Coordinating
Council’s recommendation that 5% of the net proceeds of the sale of the
A motion was made that the net proceeds
from the sale of the
A motion was made that the Coordinating Council present to the 2011 Annual Meeting a comprehensive plan for the stewardship of the net proceeds, until such time as they are allocated by the Maine Conference, shall be managed by the Board of Trustees in keeping with established Maine Conference Investment Policies. The following amendment to the motion was passed on a hand vote:”. . . unless a recommendation for the funds comes forward before the 2011 Annual Meeting in which case a special gathering will be held.
With time running out on Plenary 2, a motion to table the amended motion was passed on a hand vote.
Plenary 2 ended at 11:00 a.m.
Graduation for the first class of the Academy for Congregational Life and Leadership was held in the Dearborn Gymnasium at 1:15 p.m. Those receiving recognition were:
Arlene
Carroll,
James
Carter,
Karen Erickson, Old South Congregational Church UCC, Hallowell
Sandra Gemmel, Hampden Congregational Church UCC, Hampden
Donald
Green,
Donna Hall, Holden Congregational Church UCC, Holden
Paula
Hammerick, Old South Congregational Church UCC,
Elizabeth Hood, Phippsburg Congregational Church UCC, Phippsburg
Nancy MacArthur, Union Congregational Church UCC, Ellsworth
Ginny McGovern, Holden Congregational Church UCC, Holden
Almira Nappi, Westbrook Warren Congregational Church UCC, Westbrook
Andrea Rosenberg, First Congregational Church UCC, Buxton
Sara
Salisbury, Blue Point Congregational Church UCC,
Rebecca
Schnell, South Congregational Church UCC,
Roy
Scribner, Old South Congregational Church UCC,
Ann
Sewall, UCC of
Jane
Stegeman,
Suzanne
Stevens, First Congregational Church UCC,
Linda
Warner, First Church UCC,
Sondra Withey, Locke Mills and Rumford Point Churches UCC
Academy Director Rev. Peggy Wolfe Dunn and Academy Advisory Board Chair Rev. David Ray presented the diplomas to the graduates in a ceremony that included presentations by several of the students and a chorus made up of all the students.
Introduction of Guests: Rev. David Gaewski introduced the following (not all were present):
Rev. Carol
Howard Merritt, Western Presbyterian Church,
(keynote speaker and retreat leader)
Rev. Kent Ulrey,
President,
Rev. Daehler Hayes, Cornerstone Fund
Rev. David Williams, United Church Funds
Jeff McDonnell, United Church of Christ Insurance Board
Eric C. Smith,
Amy Porter,
Gayle Klopp, Charles Hall Youth Services
Charles Brandes, Equal Exchange Coffee
Rev. Nash
Garabedian, Seafarer’s
Recognition of Ordinations and
Anniversaries: Rev. David Gaewski, Rev. Susan Craig, and Rev. Darren Morgan
recognized the following ministers with standing in associations in the Maine
Conference who had been ordained since the last Annual Meeting and those who
are celebrating 10, 25, 35, and 50 years in the ordained ministry:
Ordination: Rev.
Judith Clark,
10-Year
Anniversary:
Rev. Diane Langworthy,
Rev. William Friedrich, Hancock-Waldo Association
Rev. Tim LeConey, Oxford Union Association
Rev. Joyce Ingrisano,
25-Year
Anniversary:
Rev.
Rev.
Richard Bennett,
Rev.
Bonnie Haase,
Rev.
Gary Haase,
35-Year
Anniversary:
Rev.
Nancy Foran,
Rev.
Peter Foss,
Rev.
David Anderman,
Rev. Jeff Belcher, Midcoast Association
Rev.
Franklin Anderson,
Rev. Dr. Kent Ulrey, Penobscot-Piscataquis Association
Rev.
Diane Wendorf,
50-Year Anniversary:
Rev.
Hartley Nutting,
Rev.
Rev.
Merle Steva,
A motion to change the afternoon schedule, placing the New Generation Committee report after the Pilgrim Lodge report, was passed on a hand vote.
Introduction of New Pastors: The following new pastors were introduced with a audio-visual presentation:
Rev. Alice Anderman serving Winthrop Congregational Church UCC
Rev. Karen Byrne serving Winslow Congregational Church UCC
Rev.
Ernie Campbell serving High Street Congregational Church in
Rev.
Stephen Carnahan serving High Street Congregational Church UCC in
Rev. Dr. Eric Kelley serving Millbridge Congregational Church UCC
Rev.
Jane McIntyre serving South Parish Congregational Church UCC in
Pastor
Jim Paar serving
Rev.
Pilgrim Lodge Task Force
Report: Rev. Anne Roundy, chair of the Pilgrim Lodge Task Force,
reviewed the charge to the Task Force from the Coordinating Council: to examine
and make recommendations concerning the recruiting, marketing, and maintenance
processes at Pilgrim Lodge and to support the Director of Outdoor Ministries in
his capacity as
Subsequent to the favorable vote, the following took place:
Next Generation Committee
Report: Denise Goodman, co-chair (with Ernie Campbell) of the Next
Generation Committee, reported on the committee’s activities since its
creation, which have included a review of the results of the “town meetings”
and interviews with Conference staff, State Youth Council officers, Association
moderators, Rev. Bryan Breault, and representatives of those who favor a deeper
Conference commitment to adult retreats. She also indicated that the Gardiner
Congregational Church had closed in January 2010 and has offered the church’s
physical and fiscal resources to the Maine Conference. The Coordinating Council
had commissioned Scott Simons Architects to determine whether the buildings
offered could be renovated to provide space for Conference offices and the
Pilgrim Lodge Report: Rev. Bryan Breault, Director of Outdoor Ministries and Pilgrim Lodge Director, reviewed the changes made in the 2010 camping program. He also described some of the physical, personnel, and fiscal needs of Pilgrim Lodge if it is to stay a viable component of the Conference’s programs. His report included a visual presentation of activities that have taken place at Pilgrim Lodge.
Discussion and Vote on Resolutions: Rev. Steve Hastings, chair of the Commission for Witness Life, introduced the Resolution on Civil Discourse, a resolution sponsored by the Maine Council of Churches and recommended by the Commission for Witness Life and the Coordinating Council. He reviewed the 6 principles included in the Resolution:
He explained that the Resolution was consistent with the principles of the Maine Conference because it was scriptural based, because many within the Conference are disturbed by the “uncivil discourse” that has overtaken much of our political and social interaction, and because it strengthens our position as a Just Peace Conference.
With very little discussion, the Resolution was passed on a hand vote.
National United
After brief discussion, the changes to the United Church of Christ Constitution were approved by the Conference on a hand vote.
He also reported that, after a brief
hiatus, trips to
Regional Youth Event Report:
Heather Gellerson and two other members of the State Youth Council reported
that the Regional Youth Event would be held at Boston University on June 24
through 27, 2010. Over 30 youth from
Installation and Rededication of Officers, Commission and Committee Members: Current and newly elected officers, commission and committee members gathered at the front of the hall. New officers and commission and committee members were installed into their positions and current officers and members were rededicated to their responsibilities.
Speak Out 2 – Moderated by Anne Roundy
Plenary 3 ended at 4:15 p.m.
Workshops – Session 2: The following workshops were scheduled from 4:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m.:
Title Room Leader
Afternoon Discussion Group
Reframing Communication
Reframing our Families
Emerging Leadership Ricker Addition Peggy Wolfe Dunn
Reframing Youth and Young
Adult Ministry Thomas Auditorium Kris Galasyn
Reframing Stewardship
Reframing Ecumenism
Conference Choir
Plenary 4 - Sunday, June 13, 2010, 8:30 – 10:00 p.m.
Speak Out 3 – Moderated by Anne Roundy
Moderator Anita White announced
that Conference Minister Rev. David Gaewski had been called to
Vice-Moderator Herb Oliver announced that Denise Goodman had been appointed Parliamentarian for Plenary 4.
2011 Clergy Compensation Guidelines: Rev. Darren Morgan, Associate Conference Minister for Small Church Development, presented the 2011 Clergy Compensation Guidelines and drew partic-ular attention to the guidelines for interim ministers, emphasizing the need to consider the years of experience when determining a fair compensation package. He also pointed out the provision for interim minister sabbatical leaves of 1 month for each year in an interim position. A motion to adopt the 2011 Clergy Compensation Guidelines was passed on a hand vote.
Resourcing the
He then announced the 12 grants that had been awarded since last fall’s Annual Meeting (totaling $21,786):
Unfinished Business: Disposition
of net proceeds of the sale of
A
motion to remove the following motion from the table was passed on a hand vote:
“That the Coordinating Council present to the 2011 Annual Meeting a comprehensive plan for the stewardship of the net proceeds, until such time as they are allocated by the Maine Conference, shall be managed by the Board of Trustees in keeping with established Maine Conference Investment Policies, unless a recommendation for the funds comes forward before the 2011 Annual Meeting in which case a special gathering will be held.”
The
person making that motion and the person seconding it requested that the
following substitute motion be accepted in place of the original motion:
“That the Coordinating Council present to the 2011 Annual Meeting or a called Special Meeting a comprehensive plan for the stewardship of the net proceeds of the sale of Rockcraft Retreat Center, which proceeds shall be held by the Maine Conference in accordance with the established Maine Conference Liquidity Policy, which governs short-term investments of Conference resources for the safety and preservation of Conference resources.
This motion was accepted as a substitute for the original motion taken from the table by a hands vote.
After brief discussion, the substitute motion was passed by a hand vote.
Credentials Committee Report: The Credentials Committee reported the following:
Lay delegates 148
Clergy delegates 86
Youth delegates 8
Voting Delegates 242
Visitors 43
Total attendance: 285
Moderator’s Remarks: Anita White acknowledged the cooperative spirit of the Coordinating Council during her 2 years as Moderator, noting that some of the decisions it needed to make had been difficult ones. She thanked Mark Doty and Martha Hoverson as chairs of the Annual Meeting Planning Committee and the excellent work of Sue Stevens in the organization and coordination of the Annual Meeting. She thanked Bob Grove-Markwood for his assistance with the audio and visual equipment. She also expressed her confidence in the newly elected Conference officers, citing their strengths and capabilities as well suited to tasks ahead.
Plenary 4 ended at approximately 9:15 a.m.
The Closing
Worship Service was held at Old South Congregational Church United Church of
Christ in
The service included recognition of 4 ministers who had died since the September 2009 Annual Meeting:
The 2009 Annual Meeting of the Maine Conference was adjourned following the worship service.